Woodminster Summer Musicals
Carousel
Woodminster Amphitheater, Oakland
July 11, 2026
In a region as climately temperate as the Bay Area, outdoor performance is a summer staple. Most years I take in one or two of these delightful al fresco experiences – at Stern Grove, Stanford’s Frost Amphitheater, Cal Shakes (RIP) or at Woodminster Amphitheater amongst the trees in the Oakland Hills. An East Bay institution, Woodminster Summer Musicals has over a half century of theatrical history. Since 1967, the group has been deeply committed to sharing a diverse collection of full-length musicals with local audiences during the summer months. Currently mid-way through its 59th season, this year’s offerings are an eclectic bunch, representing both contemporary and traditional musical theater stylings. And on Saturday evening, a good-sized house gathered to take in July’s show, Carousel, directed by Joel Schlader, choreographed by Sarah Pon and Blake Hennessy-York, with vocal direction from Debra Lambert. Over two delicious acts, the 1945 Rodgers and Hammerstein classic mined themes of youth, romance, consequence, disaster and reconciliation alongside a touch of magical realism.
Carousel’s narrative centers around the relationship between carnival hypeman Billy Bigelow and ingenue Julie Jordan, and the coastal community in which they live. Early on, they have a mutual attraction, and in (very) short course, wed. Married life is hardly a fairytale, and after a host of dark events and circumstances, tragedy eventually strikes. Life goes on, but is marred and marked by the past. And in the end, a chance is offered up which may provide some redemption and healing. Much action happens along the way amidst powerhouse vocal numbers and a beautiful ‘dream’ ballet.
Parts of the show will be tough for a 2026 viewer. Categorizing the narrative themes, conversational exchanges and gender dynamics as dated is a dramatic understatement. The show’s messaging about violence, specifically domestic violence, is both disturbing, and frankly, bizarre. And…Carousel was created in the 1940s, eight decades ago. As I watched Carousel on Saturday night, I was keenly struck by all these truths. Though I was also aware I was there to comment on this performance, by this cast, on this night and in this place and that is what follows.
![]() |
| The cast of Carousel Photo Stephen Woo & Anna Chibisova |
The Prologue Carousel Waltz transported its audience to the seaside town’s carnival, complete with a juggler, magician, stilt-artist, cotton candy and the titular carousel ride. It was colorful, dynamic and full of joy. The women’s and men’s ensemble featured many highly-trained, incredibly strong ballet dancers who delivered Pon and Hennessy-York’s movement phrases with technical proficiency, grace and confidence. It is no easy feat to choreograph interesting group sequences on a small-ish stage with a large cast, and here, there was elegance and flow to spare, and nothing looked overly fussy. Another standout dance moment came later in the Act, during the chorus’ “Hornpipe.” Celtic-inspired patterns met with percussive footwork which matched perfectly with the shanty-style music. Being a dance writer, I was mostly focused on the show’s physicality, but the strength of the leads must be mentioned. Cody Craven as Billy, Elise Walters as Julie, Ashley Garlick as Carrie, Michael Parrott as Enoch and Susan Himes-Powers as Nettie dazzled - vocally, in scenework and with undeniably commanding presence.
Dance-wise, Act II is all about the dream ballet where Billy gets to see his daughter Louise, now a teenager (danced by Pon). First comes a brief glimpse of her carefree side – long, stretchy arabesques and delicate, whimsical brisés. As characters from the town enter the picture, her posture and demeanor speak to gains in strength and confidence. But the ballet isn’t all lightness and breeze. As the score takes on a darker tonality, cancan dancers emerge from the carousel. There’s an ominous sense that the seemingly innocent carnival ride also breeds anger, temptation and danger, something Louise and her family are well versed in.
The lengthier sequence was great and the leads were terrific, but the most important aspect of Carousel’s dream ballet is that it moves the story forward. It gives Billy a chance to learn about his daughter - her personality, her struggles, her dreams, who she is. And in the 1940s, dance as a story element was somewhat new in musical theater. Choreography as more than a celebration of movement or style. Choreography as a narrative contributor, a narrative force. A trip down dance history lane will point to a number of choreographic voices who contributed to this paradigm shift. Perhaps most notable is the iconic Agnes de Mille, creator of Oklahoma’s famed dream ballet in 1943. She did it again, two years later, as the original choreographer of Carousel.




